Best fish to smoke | Top 10 smoking choices for the seafood lover

by Joost Nusselder | Last Updated:  December 15, 2021

Always the latest smoking tips & tricks?

Subscribe to THE ESSENTIAL newsletter for aspiring pitmasters

We'll only use your email address for our newsletter and respect your privacy

I love creating free content full of tips for my readers, you. I don't accept paid sponsorships, my opinion is my own, but if you find my recommendations helpful and you end up buying something you like through one of my links, I could earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more

Everyone knows about smoked salmon, especially using the cedar plank method. But, there are many more types of delicious fish you can cook in your smoker.

Are you curious to know which are the best fish for smoking?

Best fish to smoke | Top 10 smoking choices for the seafood lover

Cod, mackerel, trout, and tuna are all delicious options for your smoker. When it comes to smoking fish, the fattier, the better because they absorb the smoke wood flavor very well.

So, not only do you end up with tasty fish, but fatty fish also contains healthy omega-3 fatty acids.

In this guide, I’m sharing the best fish species to smoke.

Can you smoke any fish?

Technically, yes you can smoke any type of fish. However, it’s best to smoke fish with a high-fat content because it absorbs much more of the wood smoke aromas compared to non-fatty fish.

How to buy a bbq smoker video x
How to buy a bbq smoker video

Salmon and trout are very good for smoking because they are fatty. Mackerel tastes great too.

You can smoke fish whole or cut it into fillets and smoke it that way. Most pitmasters prefer to smoke fillets with the skin on them because this makes for very flavorful and tasty smoked fish.

Then you can use alder, oak, and other hardwoods to give the fish that delicious wood smoke aroma.

You can read all about the best wood for smoking fish in my full guide on woods for smoking fish and their respective flavor profiles here.

What fish is best for smoking?

Whether you’re sourcing your fish from the supermarket, fishmonger, or you fished it yourself, chances are it’s good for smoking.

But, if you’re looking for tried and tested amazing flavors, try the following fish species:

Salmon

The overall best fish to smoke, especially using the cedar plank method is salmon.

It is a fatty fish that absorbs the wood smoke flavors extremely well and thus ends up being very tasty when you eat it.

Also, since it has a high-fat content, salmon stays moist while you smoke it.

Look out for the Coho salmon variety because it’s one of the most sought-after and has high-quality meat.

Mackerel

Best fish to smoke mackerel is a great choice

If you’re looking for a rich fishy flavor, it’s hard to top barbeque smoked mackerel.

It’s best smoked low and slow with a hardwood, like oak. Mackerel is a very oily fish that stays moist during the smoking process.

People usually use a dry brine on this fish to bring out its delicious aromas. Mackerel is most suitable for cold smoking.

Learn more about how to cold smoke here (+ a review of the best cold smokers & generators)

Trout

If you prefer a mild fish flavor, trout is an excellent choice. It has a light, delicate texture and flavor and retains its natural moisture and juices while smoking.

When you take a bite of smoked trout you’ll notice it has a soft, melt-in-your-mouth texture which is why it’s one of the most popular types of smoked fish among people who smoke at home.

Since trout has a low mercury content compared to other fish, it is considered quite healthy.

It smokes in roughly 1.5 – 2 hours so it’s a quick and tasty smoke!

Find out which woods are best when smoking trout here

Cod

Cod, especially black cod or sablefish and butterfish as it’s also called is a great fish to smoke. It’s a good alternative to sea bass because it’s easier to get and more sustainable.

This fish has white meat and it has a very mild fishy flavor.

Cod meat is extremely soft like butter and has a very high oil content. Even the flavor is similar to butter but combined with the smoke wood aroma, it’s one of the tastiest.

Smoked cod is a good choice if you’re looking to make fish tacos.

Tuna

Tuna has a pretty strong fishy flavor and a firm texture. Its unique flavor profile makes it a perfect choice for smoking.

It tastes great when you blend it with any type of smoking wood because it pairs nicely with all types of flavors.

Ahi tuna is the tastiest variety to use in your smoker because of its high-quality reddish-pink meat. Yellowfin tuna is the second best and also flavorful.

Smoked tuna is very popular all over the world and you can preserve it for a longer period by smoking it.

Tuna is also great grilled, especially with this delicous marinade!

Sea bass

Sea bass is delicious fish to smoke, especially if you’re not the biggest seafood fan. It’s not as smelly as most other fish.

Compared to some other fish varieties like tuna, sea bass has a very mild, sweet, and delicate fishy flavor.

The fish has a high-fat content and the meat is dense. Sea bass absorbs wood smoke aromas very well and the wood smoke combined with the buttery taste of the fish is amazing.

Sturgeon

Although it’s a bit more expensive than other fish, sturgeon is a true delicacy, especially when smoked.

Sturgeon has lean meat and is full of healthy Omega-3 fatty acids. It has a firm texture that is somewhat similar to chicken but it is healthier because it’s low in sodium.

What makes sturgeon so good for smoking is that it’s a boneless fish and has a light, mild fishy flavor. Therefore, it’s easy to clean and prep for smoking and very easy to eat since there are no bones.

Bluefish

Smoked bluefish is very delicious but it’s also one of the few fish that has very tasty skin when smoked. You can definitely eat the smoked skin too and it has a strong fishy flavor.

Bluefish has a strong fishy smell and taste and is best smoked with hardwoods like mesquite and hickory that can infuse it with a lot of wood smoke.

If you use mild wood, it can’t compete with the intense bluefish taste.

In order for the bluefish to retain some of its moisture, you need to brine it ahead of smoking.

Rockfish

The Pacific Rockfish is a common fish in the Western Pacific Region of the USA and it tastes great when smoked.

It is a lean fish with a mild and delicate flavor. It leaves a nutty and sweet aftertaste so if you want to taste all the delicious aromas, it’s best to use mild smoke woods when smoking rockfish.

When smoked, this fish is very moist tender. It’s great for those who prefer milder smoked fish meat.

Sardines

Yes, you can smoke small fish like sardines too and they taste delicious.

Sardine is a salt-water fish and there are 20 species you can choose from. All of them are good for smoking because sardines have very rich and dense meat.

They are also very oily so they retain moisture and wood smoke flavor.

It’s best to smoke sardines slowly for about 5 hours using a nutty and sweet wood, like almond.

Learn about more tasty and easy ways to cook sardines at home here

Takeaway

Don’t be afraid to try smoking all types of fish. While some fish has a milder flavor than others, the fattier fish are always going to have a better smoky taste because this meat can absorb more smoke.

It’s always best to check a list of the best woods for smoking fish so you know which flavors pair well together.

Keep in mind that there’s more to smoked fish than just salmon!

Next, check out my roundup of the best meats to smoke

Joost Nusselder, the founder of Lakeside Smokers is a content marketer, dad and loves trying out new food with BBQ Smoking (& Japanese food!) at the heart of his passion, and together with his team he's been creating in-depth blog articles since 2016 to help loyal readers with recipes and cooking tips.